Following a strong and profitable start, the New York Yankees have fallen behind the Toronto Blue Jays in the American League East race. Toronto operates relatively anonymously in the baseball betting odds. But that serves to enhance their betting value. Sharps much prefer a quality Blue Jays team that offers discount prices. Meanwhile, anytime that the Yankees slump, it serves to suck bankrolls dry. The Yankees draw too much support from the casual sector, driving up their prices. At the same time, New York’s value takes a body blow. The Yankees and Blue Jays clash on Wednesday night.
New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays MLB Betting Information
| Date and Time: | Wednesday, July 23, 2025, 7:087 p.m. ET |
|---|---|
| Location: | Rogers Center, Toronto, ON |
| TV Coverage: | Amazon PRIME. |
| Team | Spread | Total | ML | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yankees | -1½ +120 | 8½ -103 | -133 |  |
| Blue Jays | +1½ -140 | 8½ -117 | +120 | |
| ||||
Yankees at Blue Jays SBG Betting Odds Analysis
Overall, the Toronto Blue Jays are the most profitable team on the MLB online betting board. Toronto is an MLB best +1131 units with the moneyline and +651 with the run line. Toronto is trending over the total this year. Additionally, Toronto is bossing the cashier’s cage at home with +1114 units.
Meanwhile, the New York Yankees have gone from a profitable team to one of the biggest money losers on the board. New York is -854 moneyline units and is -375 on the run line. Also, the Yanks are -823 on the road and are trending under the total.
New York Yankees SBG Team Overview
The New York Yankees are 53-43 and 42-52-2 under the total. Of great concern is that the Yankees are 23-24 on the road. Also, they are only 10-16 in division games. Late on, the Yankees lost eight of their most recent 13 games. New York went over the total in 12 of their last 145 matchups. The Yankees are two games behind the Blue Jays in the American League East.
In sum, the Yankees rank 3rd for run production, 1st for OPS, and 1st for home runs. The Yankees rank 13th for earned run average, 15th for quality starts, and 10th for bullpen ERA.
Toronto Blue Jays SBG Team Overview
Toronto is 55-41 and 51-44-1 over the total. First place in the American League East belongs to the Blue Jays. Late on the Jays have 13 payouts in their most recent 17 games. Seven of Toronto’s last nine games went under the total.
In sum, the Blue Jays rank 10th for run production and 10th for OPS. Toronto ranks 22nd for earned run average and 18th for quality starts. However, Toronto ranks 2nd for bullpen earned run average. Of great concern is that the Blue Jays rank 22nd for the fewest errors committed.
Right fielder George Springer leads the Blue Jays with 53 runs, 16 doubles, 16 home runs, 53 runs batted in, and an .853 OPS.
Yankees at Blue Jays SBG Free Pick
Overall, in this American League East rivalry series, Toronto beat the MLB odds in 10 of their last 17 games against the Yankees. Additionally, 15 of the most recent 19 games between the Yankees and Blue Jays have gone over the total. Specifically in Toronto, the Blue Jays got the money in nine of their last 12 games against the Yankees.
In this situation, the Blue Jays are in better form and will offer more value based on the Yankees’ public branding.
Yankees at Blue Jays SBG Best Bet: Toronto Blue Jays.