The New York Yankees are a mega brand with a generational fan base and reputation. On the other hand, the Cleveland Guardians don’t attract as much attention with the baseball betting odds. The Guardians indeed made the playoffs in six of the past nine seasons. Yet most casual gamblers either don’t know about that or choose to ignore it. The Cleveland Guardians and New York Yankees will meet on Tuesday night in a potential preview of the American League playoffs on TBS. This matchup will be a classic clash of sharps vs. squares.
Cleveland Guardians vs. New York Yankees MLB Betting Information
| Date and Time: | Tuesday, June 3, 2025, 7:05 p.m. ET |
|---|---|
| Location: | Yankee Stadium, Bronx, NY |
| TV Coverage: | TBS |
| Betting Online Odds at SBG: | Click Here |
Guardians at Yankees SBG Betting Odds Analysis
Despite their consistently high prices, the Yankees are showing a solid offshore betting profit this season. New York is in the black at Yankee Stadium and has shown its best value on the run line. Additionally, New York is trending under the total.
So far in 2025, Cleveland has shown impressively reliable betting value. The Guardians are in the black in road games as well. However, Cleveland has been a big money loser on the run line. The Guardians are breaking even with totals this season.
Of course, the Yankees are one of the biggest brands on the board. Thus, they consistently carry an expensive price in almost all games. Especially at Yankee Stadium.
By contrast, the Cleveland Guardians continue to operate under the radar. The fact that squares ignore them helps to enhance their wagering value. Squares will not be thrilled at the prospect of taking the Guardians at Yankee Stadium. Thus, bargain hunters will look at Cleveland for this matchup.
Cleveland Guardians SBG Team Overview
The Cleveland Guardians have a record of 29-25 and are 26-25-3 over the total. As a result, the Guardians are in third place behind the Detroit Tigers in the American League East. Cleveland ranks 22nd for run production and 23rd for earned run average. Of great concern are the poor metrics of the Guardians in almost every category. Cleveland’s strength is its fifth-ranked bullpen. Late on the Guardians got the money in four of their most recent seven games. Six of their last ten games went under the total.
New York Yankees SBG Team Overview
The New York Yankees are 34-20 and 22-30-2 under the total. First place in the American League East belongs to the Yankees. The Yankees are hot with ten payouts in their most recent 12 games. Also, the Yankees went under the total in ten of their last 12 games. New York has impressive metrics of third for run production, first for home runs, seventh for earned run average, and sixth for bullpen ERA.
Guardians at Yankees SBG Free Pick
Overall, in the series between the Guardians and Yankees, New York has won 13 of their most recent 19 games against Cleveland. Eight of the last 13 games between the Guardians and Yankees went over the total. Specifically at Yankee Stadium, New York, they got the cash in 11 of their latest 14 games against the Guardians. Only three of the last 11 games between the Yankees and Guardians went over the MLB odds total.
In this situation, the Yankees offer more value on the run line.
Guardians at Yankees SBG Best Bet: New York Yankees.